In focus groups in Manchester this week, we heard from young voters who had considered switching from Labour to the Greens, but now felt cautiously optimistic about Andy Burnham. This is a group frustrated by the slow pace of change under Keir Starmer's government, so for them it's encouraging that the new Prime Minister has, as John put it, "gone straight to work", although many clarified that they wanted to see real delivery before their trust was rebuilt.
I felt massively betrayed by Labour after the last general election (…) I probably would've gone more Green by now if it wasn't for the fact that I knew that Andy Burnham was coming in. So now it's almost like for me, it's not Labour versus Green. It's Green versus Andy is how I see it. Peter, videography student, Manchester
I think Andy Burnham will bring some fresh impetus and he's done a pretty good job in Manchester. So I think people are quite optimistic. I think people in this part of the country are certainly optimistic because he's got a good track record over here and he's already sort of seems like he's gone straight to work. John, IT, Manchester
He's delivered. And he's genuine. You can relate to him. He's been in our shoes. He's grown up (…) in a working class family. So I think there's a lot to relate to him. Whether he's going to deliver or not, that's another question. Jabeen, housing officer, Manchester
But Labour have also made significant gains among Rooted Patriots, increasing their vote share by 8 points since May. Reform UK led this group by 19 points just a few months ago; that lead has now gone, with the Conservatives level with Reform and Labour just 7 points behind. These voters - who overlap with the "Red Wall" swing voters that have been crucial in recent elections - are once again very much to play for. In focus groups, the Nigel Farage’s recent controversies had given them pause for thought, they were impressed by Kemi Badenoch and, in many cases, willing to give Burnham a hearing.
I voted Reform because I was fed up with what's going on today. Not that he could [do it]. If he would've got in as prime minister, God knows what he'd do. But I don't care. He said he was going to do what I want (…) I want a complete change. Tony, retired, Tameside
We do need change. I think a lot of people would vote Reform, but there's just this annoying right-wing element that seems to follow, unfortunately. A lot of it's going to be bastardised by social media and the news. But actually I think we do need change. Scott, retired, Tameside
There are still challenges for Burnham elsewhere: Labour's vote share has stagnated among Established Liberals and Sceptical Scrollers, and dropped among Traditional Conservatives. In next week's episode of the Opinion Brief Podcast, we'll be looking at each segment, and what their changing voting intention tells us about the state of British politics.
Once again, it's too early to tell how far this bounce can go, and how long it will last once the government gets into the practicalities of governing. But it's clear that Burnham's bounce is about more than reigniting the base. The choice to spend his first weeks hyper-focused on the most unifying issue in our politics - the cost of living - might give him more license to engage in the trickier, long term conversations.
In those same focus groups, some young progressive voters said Burnham was one of the few politicians both they and their conservative grandparents thought were "all right".
My parents are more Tory than me and my grandparents are more Tory than them. And I'm more Labour. And you can't get them to like anything that Labour does most of the time, especially my grandma. But she loves Andy. So I'm sure it's just because she can see how much of a good job he's done. Peter, videography student, Manchester
My family, they are Conservatives and they also like Andy Burnham, which is quite telling because we can't agree on anything else apart from the fact that Andy Burnham's all right. John, IT, Manchester
Greater Manchester decides
It’s just hours until we get the results from the Greater Manchester Mayoral By-Election, and our poll of Greater Manchester this week suggests the contest is being fought on many of the same issues that are shaping our national politics. Cost of living is the top issue, named by 51 per cent as one of the biggest facing the city-region. Crime and antisocial behaviour comes second on 30 per cent, ahead of access to the NHS on 25 per cent and housing on 24 per cent. |
|